The organization responsible for the oldest Island-wide award, honoring a graduating high school scholar-athlete, was founded against the backdrop of the Great Depression.
1942
Lawrence Paugh (Tottenville High School)
1941
Donald Currie (Curtis High School)
1940
Michael Tighe (St. Peter's High School)
1939
Edward Wholihan (Curtis High School)
1938
Arnold Anderson (Port Richmond High School)
